Commodity Dilemma:

The Commodity Dilemma: Navigating Volatility with Clarity
Yesterday was a mistake. Tomorrow might be a blunder.

This is the silent fear in the minds of many business owners and channel partners dealing with commodity-driven industries like TMT bars.

The challenge is multifaceted:

• Raw material prices fluctuate unpredictably.
• Finished goods pricing is linked to raw material costs at the time of sale.
• The lead time between buying raw materials and selling finished goods is long.
• Raw materials are typically purchased in cash, while finished goods are sold on credit.

This creates a long cash-to-cash cycle, often stretching 90 to 120 days. In such a scenario, the question always looms:

Should you buy now and risk a price drop? Or wait, risk shortages, and lose sales?

Many attempt to predict demand, forecast prices, and find that elusive “sweet spot.” But in reality, this timing-the-market gamble rarely works.

The Vicious Cycle of Volatility

Here’s what often happens in such environments:

• Excess inventory up cash while adding no immediate value.
• Stockoutsoccur at critical moments, eroding sales and channel confidence.
• Delayed receivables stretch the credit cycle, creating further financial strain.

Ultimately, manufacturers, distributors, and customers all feel the ripple effects.

Rethinking Conventional Assumptions

One of the most damaging assumptions in commodity trade is that extending credit is the only way to sustain business. In volatile markets, this practice can exacerbate cash flow issues and deepen the impact of price swings.Instead, the focus should shift to reducing the cash-to-cash cycle and making decisions less vulnerable to unpredictable market movements.

Practical Steps to Manage Volatility

Based on extensive implementation experience in commodity-driven industries, a few practical interventions have consistently proven effective:

Offering upfront cash discounts of up to 15%

Reducing minimum order quantities (MOQ) by as much as 75%

Cutting delivery lead times by more than 80%

Providing short-term price protection to channel partners

Aligning replenishment more closely with real demand signals

These measures have helped companies significantly reduce financial exposure, improve liquidity, and increase market responsiveness—even in highly volatile environments.

In several implementations, these approaches have cut cash-to-cash cycles by over 50%, stabilized pricing decisions, and restored confidence across the entire supply chain.

A Real-World Example

In one implementation with a mid-sized steel products distributor, these measures transformed their operations within just six months:

• Cash-to-cash cycle reduced by 55%
• Stockouts dropped by 70%, improving channel confidence
• Sales volumes increased by 35% despite market volatility
• Working capital freed up significantly, enabling better market reach

What started as a business constantly firefighting against price swings became a stable, agile, and more profitable operation.

From Firefighting to Stability

As one dealer put it:

“Earlier, timing purchases felt like a trap—yesterday was a mistake, and tomorrow might be a blunder. Now, focusing on shorter decision cycles shields us from both price and quantity volatility.”

Volatility may be inevitable, but how it impacts your business doesn’t have to be.

What’s the takeaway?
Price swings can’t be controlled, but the way you manage your supply chain, cash flow, and channel relationships can make all the difference.

What has worked best for you in navigating commodity volatility? Share your thoughts.

info@tocguru.in +91 94444 57518

The Commodity Dilemma: Navigating Volatility with Clarity